BARBY INGLE- For Arizona State Representative District 7
Solar farms require vast areas of land, often hundreds or thousands of acres, leading to several criticisms:
- Land use and loss of agricultural/farmland — They can displace productive farmland or prime agricultural soil, potentially fueling competition between energy developers and farmers, and contributing to long-term food production concerns in some regions.
- Habitat disruption and biodiversity loss — Clearing land fragments ecosystems, displaces wildlife (e.g., desert tortoises or other species), and blocks sunlight, preventing vegetation growth underneath panels in many cases.
- Visual and aesthetic impact — The stark appearance of rows of panels alters rural landscapes, often described as industrial or unattractive, reducing scenic value and potentially affecting tourism or property values.
- Intermittency and grid reliability issues — Output depends on sunlight (zero at night or during heavy cloud cover), requiring backup power (often fossil fuels) or expensive storage, which some view as making them less reliable than dispatchable sources.
- High upfront costs and economic concerns — Building utility-scale projects is capital-intensive (often millions per megawatt), with long payback periods; critics argue subsidies distort markets or that funds could go elsewhere (e.g., nuclear).
- Other environmental drawbacks — Construction causes soil erosion, stormwater runoff issues, and potential long-term waste from panel disposal (though recycling is improving); some raise concerns about heat island effects or minor wildlife impacts.
Wind farms, especially onshore, face opposition due to their visibility, wildlife effects, and other factors:
- Wildlife impacts, particularly birds and bats — Turbine blades can kill flying animals through collisions; while overall population effects are often low compared to other causes (e.g., buildings or cats), certain migratory species or low-reproduction populations face higher risks.
- Noise and infrasound — Audible noise from blades and low-frequency infrasound can disturb nearby residents, leading to complaints about sleep disruption or health effects (though studies vary on severity).
- Visual and landscape alteration — Tall turbines (often 300+ feet) dominate skylines, creating “industrial” views in rural or scenic areas, which opponents say harms aesthetics, property values, and tourism.
- Land use and habitat fragmentation — Though turbines themselves occupy little space (allowing farming/grazing underneath), access roads, foundations, and transmission lines fragment habitats and alter ecosystems.
- Intermittency and unreliability — Power varies with wind speeds (zero in calm conditions), requiring grid backups and potentially increasing system costs for storage or peaker plants.
- Other concerns — Construction/mining for rare earth metals and critical minerals has environmental costs; some studies suggest very large-scale farms could have minor regional climate effects (e.g., slight warming from atmospheric mixing); decommissioning old turbines leaves waste if not managed well.
Integrity & Transparency – Barby supports the need for election integrity and transparency.
- Election/ Voting
- Government Operations
- Border Control
- Illegal Immigration vs Immigration
- Supports the Constitution of the United States and Arizona
Law and Order – Barby supports ensuring that our first responders have the resources to protect and serve Arizonans.
- Border Control
- Support for Military, Police, Fire, and First Responders
- Supports Equal Justice For All
- Supports Laws That Lower Violent Crime
Economic – Barby supports policies that fairly balance the community’s needs with the concerns of existing Arizonans. She will do this through a fiscal conservatism view, which includes support for lower taxes, smaller government, free market capitalism, free trade, deregulation of corporations, and restrictions on labor unions.
- Affordable Housing
- Charities
- Consumer Financial Protection
- Consumer Protection
- Labor & Employment Law
- Securities
- Improve Taxes and Strengthening our businesses
Healthcare – Barby supports getting proper and timely care for all in need, and especially Arizonans living with rare and chronic diseases.
- Access To Care
- Treatment Options
- Individualized Care
- Cannabis
- COVID-19 Coronavirus
- Environment
- Ethics
- Patient Privacy
- Patient-Provider Rights
- Injury Prevention and Safety
- Policies that ensure access to private, proper and timely care that is individualized
- Treatment Options
- Chronic and Rare Diseases
- Access to Care
- Prevention, Education, and Advocacy, RDAC, CIAC
- Stopping poor insurance practices such as Step Therapy, Prior Authorization
- Addiction – Combating addiction challenges
- Gaming/ Gambling
- Substances
- E-Cigarettes
- Drugs
- Alcohol
- Prevention, Education, and Advocacy
State Infrastructure – Barby supports policies that fairly balance the community’s future needs with the concerns of existing Arizonans.
- State v. Federal
- Transportation
- Utilities
Barby believes that the Republican Party encompasses a range of perspectives, including corporate, libertarian, populist, evangelical, and MAGA factions, which differ on issues such as trade, foreign policy, and social concerns. Despite internal tensions, particularly between establishment and grassroots supporters, the party maintains national unity while showing local diversity.
For example, we fall into one or more of these categories of Republican, but we are all still united under the National banner of the Republican.
-
-
Corporate Republicans: Favor low taxes, deregulation, and free-market policies, often aligned with big business and traditional Reaganomics.
-
Libertarians: Emphasize individual liberty, limited government, and skepticism of federal overreach, often opposing social regulations.
-
Populists/Nativists: Focus on working-class interests, trade protectionism, and strict immigration policies, energized by Trump’s “America First” agenda.
-
Evangelical Christians: Prioritize social conservatism, including opposition to abortion and support for traditional values, often with a religious foundation.
-
MAGA Republicans: Loyal to Trump’s populist rhetoric, skeptical of corporate elites and globalism, and focused on cultural and national identity.
-
Reaganites: Advocate for tax cuts, strong national defense, and global U.S. leadership, rooted in Reagan-era conservatism.
-
Education – Prioritizing Students and Teachers in the Classroom – Barby supports accountability to ensure that our tax dollars are spent wisely to benefit our students.
- Classroom Size/Overcrowding
- Data Privacy & Security
- Quality Teachers
- Voucher Programs/ School Choice